Summary:
In addition to removing the earlier partially implemented garbage collection
logic from the BlobDB codebase, the patch also removes the test cases (as well as
the related sync points, as appropriate) that were only relevant for the old
implementation, and reworks the remaining ones so they use the new GC logic.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6278
Test Plan: `make check`
Differential Revision: D19335226
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 0cc1794bc9892feda1426ed5522a318f3cb1b692
Summary:
BlobDB currently only supports using the default column family. The earlier
code enforces this by comparing the `ColumnFamilyHandle` passed to the
`Get`/`Put`/etc. call with the handle returned by `DefaultColumnFamily`
(which, at the end of the day, comes from `DBImpl::default_cf_handle_`).
Since other `ColumnFamilyHandle`s can also point to the default column
family, this can reject legitimate requests as well. (As an example,
with the earlier code, the handle returned by `BlobDB::Open` cannot
actually be used in API calls.) The patch fixes this by comparing only
the IDs of the column family handles instead of the pointers themselves.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6226
Test Plan: `make check`
Differential Revision: D19187461
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 54ce2e12ebb1f07e6d1e70e3b1e0213dfa94bda2
Summary:
Periodic compactions ensure that even SSTs that do not get picked up
otherwise eventually go through compaction; used in conjunction with
BlobDB's garbage collection, they enable BlobDB to reclaim space when
old blob files are used by such straggling SSTs.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6172
Test Plan: Ran `make check` and used the BlobDB mode of `db_bench`.
Differential Revision: D19045045
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 04636ecc4b6cfe8d495bf656faa65d54a5eb1a93
Summary:
The current Env API encompasses both storage/file operations, as well as OS related operations. Most of the APIs return a Status, which does not have enough metadata about an error, such as whether its retry-able or not, scope (i.e fault domain) of the error etc., that may be required in order to properly handle a storage error. The file APIs also do not provide enough control over the IO SLA, such as timeout, prioritization, hinting about placement and redundancy etc.
This PR separates out the file/storage APIs from Env into a new FileSystem class. The APIs are updated to return an IOStatus with metadata about the error, as well as to take an IOOptions structure as input in order to allow more control over the IO.
The user can set both ```options.env``` and ```options.file_system``` to specify that RocksDB should use the former for OS related operations and the latter for storage operations. Internally, a ```CompositeEnvWrapper``` has been introduced that inherits from ```Env``` and redirects individual methods to either an ```Env``` implementation or the ```FileSystem``` as appropriate. When options are sanitized during ```DB::Open```, ```options.env``` is replaced with a newly allocated ```CompositeEnvWrapper``` instance if both env and file_system have been specified. This way, the rest of the RocksDB code can continue to function as before.
This PR also ports PosixEnv to the new API by splitting it into two - PosixEnv and PosixFileSystem. PosixEnv is defined as a sub-class of CompositeEnvWrapper, and threading/time functions are overridden with Posix specific implementations in order to avoid an extra level of indirection.
The ```CompositeEnvWrapper``` translates ```IOStatus``` return code to ```Status```, and sets the severity to ```kSoftError``` if the io_status is retryable. The error handling code in RocksDB can then recover the DB automatically.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5761
Differential Revision: D18868376
Pulled By: anand1976
fbshipit-source-id: 39efe18a162ea746fabac6360ff529baba48486f
Summary:
The patch adds logic that relocates live blobs from the oldest N non-TTL
blob files as they are encountered during compaction (assuming the BlobDB
configuration option `enable_garbage_collection` is `true`), where N is defined
as the number of immutable non-TTL blob files multiplied by the value of
a new BlobDB configuration option called `garbage_collection_cutoff`.
(The default value of this parameter is 0.25, that is, by default the valid blobs
residing in the oldest 25% of immutable non-TTL blob files are relocated.)
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6121
Test Plan: Added unit test and tested using the BlobDB mode of `db_bench`.
Differential Revision: D18785357
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 8c21c512a18fba777ec28765c88682bb1a5e694e
Summary:
This patch factors out the logic that reads a (potentially compressed) blob
from a file into a separate helper method `GetRawBlobFromFile`, and cleans
up the code a bit. Also, errors during decompression are now logged/propagated
to the user by returning a `Status` code of `Corruption`.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6093
Test Plan: `make check`
Differential Revision: D18716673
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 44144bc064cab616862d5643f34384f2bae6eb78
Summary:
The patch refactors and cleans up the logic around creating new blob files
by moving the common code of `SelectBlobFile` and `SelectBlobFileTTL`
to a new helper method `CreateBlobFileAndWriter`, bringing the implementation
of `SelectBlobFile` and `SelectBlobFileTTL` into sync, and increasing encapsulation
by adding new constructors for `BlobFile` and `BlobLogHeader`.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6066
Test Plan:
Ran `make check` and used the BlobDB mode of `db_bench` to sanity test both
the TTL and the non-TTL code paths.
Differential Revision: D18646921
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: e5705a84807932e31dccab4f49b3e64369cea26d
Summary:
The patch adds logic to mark no longer needed blob files obsolete upon database open
and whenever a flush or compaction completes. Unneeded blob files are detected by
iterating through live immutable non-TTL blob files starting from the lowest-numbered one,
and stopping when a blob file used by any SSTs or potentially used by memtables is found.
(The latter is determined by comparing the sequence number at which the blob file
became immutable with the largest sequence number received in flush notifications.)
In addition, the patch cleans up the logic around closing and obsoleting blob files and
enforces invariants around this area (blob files are now guaranteed to go through the
stages mutable-non-obsolete, immutable-non-obsolete, and immutable-obsolete in this
order).
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6032
Test Plan: Extended unit tests and tested using the BlobDB mode of `db_bench`.
Differential Revision: D18495610
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 11825b84af74f3f4abfd9bcae04e80870ae58961
Summary:
The patch adds logic to BlobDB to maintain the mapping between blob files
and SSTs for which the blob file in question is the oldest blob file referenced
by the SST file. The mapping is initialized during database open based on the
information retrieved using `GetLiveFilesMetaData`, and updated after
flushes/compactions based on the information received through the `EventListener`
interface (or, in the case of manual compactions issued through the `CompactFiles`
API, the `CompactionJobInfo` object).
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/6020
Test Plan: Added a unit test; also tested using the BlobDB mode of `db_bench`.
Differential Revision: D18410508
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: dd9e778af781cfdb0d7056298c54ba9cebdd54a5
Summary:
- Periodic compactions are auto-enabled if a compaction filter or a compaction filter factory is set, in Level Compaction.
- The default value of `periodic_compaction_seconds` is changed to UINT64_MAX, which lets RocksDB auto-tune periodic compactions as needed. An explicit value of 0 will still work as before ie. to disable periodic compactions completely. For now, on seeing a compaction filter along with a UINT64_MAX value for `periodic_compaction_seconds`, RocksDB will make SST files older than 30 days to go through periodic copmactions.
Some RocksDB users make use of compaction filters to control when their data can be deleted, usually with a custom TTL logic. But it is occasionally possible that the compactions get delayed by considerable time due to factors like low writes to a key range, data reaching bottom level, etc before the TTL expiry. Periodic Compactions feature was originally built to help such cases. Now periodic compactions are auto enabled by default when compaction filters or compaction filter factories are used, as it is generally helpful to all cases to collect garbage.
`periodic_compaction_seconds` is set to a large value, 30 days, in `SanitizeOptions` when RocksDB sees that a `compaction_filter` or `compaction_filter_factory` is used.
This is done only for Level Compaction style.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5865
Test Plan:
- Added a new test `DBCompactionTest.LevelPeriodicCompactionWithCompactionFilters` to make sure that `periodic_compaction_seconds` is set if either `compaction_filter` or `compaction_filter_factory` options are set.
- `COMPILE_WITH_ASAN=1 make check`
Differential Revision: D17659180
Pulled By: sagar0
fbshipit-source-id: 4887b9cf2e53cf2dc93a7b658c6b15e1181217ee
Summary:
file_reader_writer.h and .cc contain several files and helper function, and it's hard to navigate. Separate it to multiple files and put them under file/
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5803
Test Plan: Build whole project using make and cmake.
Differential Revision: D17374550
fbshipit-source-id: 10efca907721e7a78ed25bbf74dc5410dea05987
Summary:
Some accesses to blob_files_ and open_ttl_files_ in BlobDBImpl, as well
as to expiration_range_ in BlobFile were not properly synchronized.
The patch fixes this and also makes sure the invariant that obsolete_files_
is a subset of blob_files_ holds even when an attempt to delete an obsolete
blob file fails.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5698
Test Plan:
COMPILE_WITH_TSAN=1 make blob_db_test
gtest-parallel --repeat=1000 ./blob_db_test --gtest_filter="*ShutdownWait*"
The test fails with TSAN errors ~20 times out of 1000 without the patch but
completes successfully 1000 out of 1000 times with the fix.
Differential Revision: D16793235
Pulled By: ltamasi
fbshipit-source-id: 8034b987598d4fdc9f15098d4589cc49cde484e9
Summary:
This is a new API added to db.h to allow for fetching all merge operands associated with a Key. The main motivation for this API is to support use cases where doing a full online merge is not necessary as it is performance sensitive. Example use-cases:
1. Update subset of columns and read subset of columns -
Imagine a SQL Table, a row is encoded as a K/V pair (as it is done in MyRocks). If there are many columns and users only updated one of them, we can use merge operator to reduce write amplification. While users only read one or two columns in the read query, this feature can avoid a full merging of the whole row, and save some CPU.
2. Updating very few attributes in a value which is a JSON-like document -
Updating one attribute can be done efficiently using merge operator, while reading back one attribute can be done more efficiently if we don't need to do a full merge.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
API :
Status GetMergeOperands(
const ReadOptions& options, ColumnFamilyHandle* column_family,
const Slice& key, PinnableSlice* merge_operands,
GetMergeOperandsOptions* get_merge_operands_options,
int* number_of_operands)
Example usage :
int size = 100;
int number_of_operands = 0;
std::vector<PinnableSlice> values(size);
GetMergeOperandsOptions merge_operands_info;
db_->GetMergeOperands(ReadOptions(), db_->DefaultColumnFamily(), "k1", values.data(), merge_operands_info, &number_of_operands);
Description :
Returns all the merge operands corresponding to the key. If the number of merge operands in DB is greater than merge_operands_options.expected_max_number_of_operands no merge operands are returned and status is Incomplete. Merge operands returned are in the order of insertion.
merge_operands-> Points to an array of at-least merge_operands_options.expected_max_number_of_operands and the caller is responsible for allocating it. If the status returned is Incomplete then number_of_operands will contain the total number of merge operands found in DB for key.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5604
Test Plan:
Added unit test and perf test in db_bench that can be run using the command:
./db_bench -benchmarks=getmergeoperands --merge_operator=sortlist
Differential Revision: D16657366
Pulled By: vjnadimpalli
fbshipit-source-id: 0faadd752351745224ee12d4ae9ef3cb529951bf
Summary:
1. Cleanup WAL trash files on open
2. Don't apply deletion rate limit if WAL dir is different from db dir
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5520
Test Plan: Add new unit tests and make check
Differential Revision: D16096750
Pulled By: anand1976
fbshipit-source-id: 6f07858ad864b754b711db416f0389c45ede599b
Summary:
If a memtable definitely covers a key, there isn't a need to check older memtables.
We can skip them by checking the earliest sequence number.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4941
Differential Revision: D13932666
fbshipit-source-id: b9d52f234b8ad9dd3bf6547645cd457175a3ca9b
Summary:
Many logging related source files are under util/. It will be more structured if they are together.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5387
Differential Revision: D15579036
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 3850134ed50b8c0bb40a0c8ae1f184fa4081303f
Summary:
There are too many types of files under util/. Some test related files don't belong to there or just are just loosely related. Mo
ve them to a new directory test_util/, so that util/ is cleaner.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5377
Differential Revision: D15551366
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 0f5c8653832354ef8caa31749c0143815d719e2c
Summary:
util/ means for lower level libraries, so it's a good idea to move the files which requires knowledge to DB out. Create a file/ and move some files there.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5375
Differential Revision: D15550935
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 61a9715dcde5386eebfb43e93f847bba1ae0d3f2
Summary:
Annotate all of the logging functions to inform the compiler that these
use printf-style formatting arguments. This allows the compiler to emit
warnings if the format arguments are incorrect.
This also fixes many problems reported now that format string checking
is enabled. Many of these are simply mix-ups in the argument type (e.g,
int vs uint64_t), but in several cases the wrong number of arguments
were being passed in which can cause the code to crash.
The primary motivation for this was to fix the log message in
`DBImpl::SwitchMemtable()` which caused a segfault due to an extra %s
format parameter with no argument supplied.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5089
Differential Revision: D14574795
Pulled By: simpkins
fbshipit-source-id: 0921b03f0743652bf4ae21e414ff54b3bb65422a
Summary:
Right now, BlobDB::Open() fails to put all trash files to delete scheduler,
which causes some trash files permanently untracked.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5103
Differential Revision: D14606095
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 41a9437a2948abb235c0ed85f9a04612d0e50183
Summary:
This is a feature to sample data-block compressibility and and report them as stats. 1 in N (tunable) blocks is sampled for compressibility using two algorithms:
1. lz4 or snappy for fast compression
2. zstd or zlib for slow but higher compression.
The stats are reported to the caller as raw-bytes and compressed-bytes. The block continues to be compressed for storage using the specified CompressionType.
The db_bench_tool how has a command line option for specifying the sampling rate. It's default value is 0 (no sampling). To test the overhead for a certain value, users can compare the performance of db_bench_tool, varying the sampling rate. It is unlikely to have a noticeable impact for high values like 20.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4842
Differential Revision: D13629011
Pulled By: shobhitdayal
fbshipit-source-id: 14ca668bcab6499b2a1734edf848eb62a4f4fafa
Summary:
Statistics cost too much CPU for some use cases. Add two stats levels
so that people can choose to skip two types of expensive stats, timers and
histograms.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5027
Differential Revision: D14252765
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 75ecec9eaa44c06118229df4f80c366115346592
Summary:
When closing a BlobDB, it only waits for background tasks
to finish as the last thing, but the background task may access
some variables that are destroyed. The fix is to introduce a
shutdown function in the timer queue and call the function as
the first thing when destorying BlobDB.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/5005
Differential Revision: D14170342
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: 081e6a2d99b9765d5956cf6cdfc290c07270c233
Summary:
Blob DB files are not tracked by the SFM, so they currently don't get
deleted in the background. Force them to be deleted in background so
rate limiting can be applied
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4928
Differential Revision: D13854649
Pulled By: anand1976
fbshipit-source-id: 8031ce66842ff0af440c715d886b377983dad7d8
Summary:
Right now, deleting blob files is not rate limited, even if SstFileManger is specified.
On the other hand, rate limiting blob deletion is not supported. With this change, Blob file
deletion will go through SstFileManager too.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4904
Differential Revision: D13772545
Pulled By: siying
fbshipit-source-id: bd1b1d0beb26d5167385e00b7ecb8b94b879de84
Summary:
Remove unused blob WAL filter so that users are not confused.
I was initially under the impression that we have WAL Filter support in BlobDB.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4896
Differential Revision: D13725709
Pulled By: sagar0
fbshipit-source-id: f997d7546e138a474036e88b957907cc714327f1
Summary:
This is essentially a re-submission of #4251 with a few improvements:
- Split `CompressionDict` into two separate classes: `CompressionDict` and `UncompressionDict`
- Eliminated `Init` functions. Instead do all initialization work in constructors.
- Added test case for parallel DB open, which is the scenario where #4251 failed under TSAN.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4849
Differential Revision: D13606039
Pulled By: ajkr
fbshipit-source-id: 08c236059798c710db9cbf545fce0f371232d447
Summary:
A fix similar to #4410 but on the write path. On IO error on `SelectBlobFile()` we didn't return error code properly, but simply a nullptr of `BlobFile`. The `AppendBlob()` method didn't have null check for the pointer and caused crash. The fix make sure we properly return error code in this case.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4580
Differential Revision: D10513849
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: 80bca920d1d7a3541149de981015ad83e0aa14b5
Summary:
- Fix DBImpl API race condition
The timeline of execution flow is as follow:
```
timeline user_thread1 user_thread2
t1 | cfh = GetColumnFamilyHandleUnlocked(0)
t2 | id1 = cfh->GetID()
t3 | GetColumnFamilyHandleUnlocked(1)
t4 | id2 = cfh->GetID()
V
```
The original implementation return a pointer to a stateful variable, so that the return `ColumnFamilyHandle` will be changed when another thread calls `GetColumnFamilyHandleUnlocked` with different `column family id`
- Expose ColumnFamily ID to compaction event listener
- Fix the return status of `DBImpl::GetLatestSequenceForKey`
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4391
Differential Revision: D10221243
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: dec60ee9ff0c8261a2f2413a8506ec1063991993
Summary:
Fix IO error on read not being handle and crashing the DB. With the fix we properly return the error.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4410
Differential Revision: D9979246
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: 111a85675067a29c03cb60e9a34103f4ff636694
Summary:
Reverting is needed to unblock a user building against master, who is blocked for multiple days due to a thread-safety issue in `GetEmptyDict`. We haven't been able to fix it quickly, so reverting.
Simply ran `git revert 6c40806e51a89386d2b066fddf73d3fd03a36f65`. There were no merge conflicts.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4347
Differential Revision: D9668365
Pulled By: ajkr
fbshipit-source-id: 0c56334f0a23cf5ee0233d4e4679eae6709739cd
Summary:
As you know, almost all compilers support "pragma once" keyword instead of using include guards. To be keep consistency between header files, all header files are edited.
Besides this, try to fix some warnings about loss of data.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4339
Differential Revision: D9654990
Pulled By: ajkr
fbshipit-source-id: c2cf3d2d03a599847684bed81378c401920ca848
Summary:
When reading an expired key using `Get(..., std::string* value)` API, BlobDB first read the index entry and decode expiration from it. In this case, although BlobDB reset the PinnableSlice, the index entry is stored in user provided string `value`. The value will be returned as a garbage value, despite status being NotFound. Fixing it by use a different PinnableSlice to read the index entry.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4321
Differential Revision: D9519042
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: f054c951a1fa98265228be94f931904ed7056677
Summary:
`DB::DiableFileDeletions` and `DB::EnableFileDeletions` are used for applications to stop RocksDB background jobs to delete files while they are doing replication. Implement these methods for BlobDB. `DeleteObsolteFiles` now needs to check `disable_file_deletions_` before starting, and will hold `delete_file_mutex_` the whole time while it is running. `DisableFileDeletions` needs to wait on `delete_file_mutex_` for running `DeleteObsolteFiles` job and set `disable_file_deletions_` flag.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4314
Differential Revision: D9501373
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: 81064c1228f1724eff46da22b50ff765b16292cd
Summary:
In RocksDB, for a given SST file, all data blocks are compressed with the same dictionary. When we compress a block using the dictionary's raw bytes, the compression library first has to digest the dictionary to get it into a usable form. This digestion work is redundant and ideally should be done once per file.
ZSTD offers APIs for the caller to create and reuse a digested dictionary object (`ZSTD_CDict`). In this PR, we call `ZSTD_createCDict` once per file to digest the raw bytes. Then we use `ZSTD_compress_usingCDict` to compress each data block using the pre-digested dictionary. Once the file's created `ZSTD_freeCDict` releases the resources held by the digested dictionary.
There are a couple other changes included in this PR:
- Changed the parameter object for (un)compression functions from `CompressionContext`/`UncompressionContext` to `CompressionInfo`/`UncompressionInfo`. This avoids the previous pattern, where `CompressionContext`/`UncompressionContext` had to be mutated before calling a (un)compression function depending on whether dictionary should be used. I felt that mutation was error-prone so eliminated it.
- Added support for digested uncompression dictionaries (`ZSTD_DDict`) as well. However, this PR does not support reusing them across uncompression calls for the same file. That work is deferred to a later PR when we will store the `ZSTD_DDict` objects in block cache.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4251
Differential Revision: D9257078
Pulled By: ajkr
fbshipit-source-id: 21b8cb6bbdd48e459f1c62343780ab66c0a64438
Summary:
We want to sample the file I/O issued by RocksDB and report the function calls. This requires us to include the file paths otherwise it's hard to tell what has been going on.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4039
Differential Revision: D8670178
Pulled By: riversand963
fbshipit-source-id: 97ee806d1c583a2983e28e213ee764dc6ac28f7a
Summary:
Fix expired file not being evicted from the DB. We have a background task (previously called `CheckSeqFiles` and I rename it to `EvictExpiredFiles`) to scan and remove expired files, but it only close the files, not marking them as expired.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4294
Differential Revision: D9415984
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: eff7bf0331c52a7ccdb02318602bff7f64f3ef3d
Summary:
Add API to allow fetching expiration of a key with `Get()`.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4227
Differential Revision: D9169897
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: 2a6f216c493dc75731ddcef1daa689b517fab31b
Summary:
There are two issues with `VisibleToActiveSnapshot`:
1. If there are no snapshots, `oldest_snapshot` will be 0 and `VisibleToActiveSnapshot` will always return true. Since the method is used to decide whether it is safe to delete obsolete files, obsolete file won't be able to delete in this case.
2. The `auto` keyword of `auto snapshots = db_impl_->snapshots()` translate to a copy of `const SnapshotList` instead of a reference. Since copy constructor of `SnapshotList` is not defined, using the copy may yield unexpected result.
Issue 2 actually hide issue 1 from being catch by tests. During test `snapshots.empty()` can return false while it should actually be empty, and `snapshots.oldest()` return an invalid address, making `oldest_snapshot` being some random large number.
The issue was originally reported by BlobDB early adopter at Kuaishou.
Pull Request resolved: https://github.com/facebook/rocksdb/pull/4236
Differential Revision: D9188706
Pulled By: yiwu-arbug
fbshipit-source-id: a0f2624b927cf9bf28c1bb534784fee5d106f5ea
Levi Tamasi